Peanut Butter Ice Cream

Made with just 5 ingredients, this homemade Peanut Butter Ice Cream is sweet and creamy, and incredibly easy to make. Top with hot fudge sauce for a quick and easy homemade ice cream sundae!

Creamy & Dreamy Peanut Butter Ice Cream

Peanut Butter Ice Cream makes me HAPPY!!

We’ve been enjoying this homemade peanut butter ice cream recipe for many years; it’s so crazy easy to make. Just throw some peanut butter and four other ingredients in a blender, and chill it in the fridge. Then freeze the mixture in an ice cream maker and let the machine work its magic.

That’s all it takes for delicious, creamy, peanut buttery frozen yum!

While peanut butter ice cream can certainly be enjoyed all on its own, I just have to say, “What’s peanut butter without chocolate?!” Our family has a strong commitment to the PB + chocolate combo. So I highly recommend serving this up with a drizzle of easy homemade hot fudge sauce or chocolate magic shell over the top. It’s fantastic!

More Ice Cream Recipes: Butter Pecan Ice Cream is full of luscious buttery caramel flavor and studded with salty, crunchy toasted pecans. Cookie Monster Ice Cream is super fun with its blue color, and so yummy with its fresh vanilla bean flavor, plus bites of cookie dough and Oreos. And Chocolate Malt Banana Ice Cream, a copycat version of one of my favorite flavors from a local Minnesota ice cream shop!

What You’ll Need

Whenever I make this ice cream, I’m always amazed by the simplicity of the recipe. This homemade peanut butter ice cream requires just 5 basic ingredients!

• Peanut butter – Any brand of creamy peanut butter will work. I prefer Jif.
• Sugar
• Half-and-half – The “cream” part of this ice cream.
• Salt – Just a little bit plays so well with the sweetness and peanut butter.
• Vanilla extract – For added flavor.

How to Make Peanut Butter Ice Cream

You’ll love how easy it is to make a perfectly creamy peanut butter ice cream at home. The hardest part is waiting for it to chill!

• Combine the ingredients. Puree all ingredients in a blender or food processor until smooth.
• Chill. Chill the mixture in the fridge.
• Freeze. Freeze the mixture in an ice cream maker.

Tips for Success

Although this ice cream is super easy to make, these tips may be helpful:

• Become familiar with your ice cream maker. If you haven’t made ice cream at home before, take a little time to read through the instructions of your ice cream maker before you start. Most machines require that you freeze the bowl for a full 24 hours prior to making ice cream.
• Puree the ingredients fully. This step ensures a smooth, creamy ice cream without lumps.
• Chill before freezing. You’ll need to chill the pureed mixture before adding it to the ice cream machine.
• Freeze before scooping. Though it’s tempting to dive into the ice cream straight from the machine, it will have a softer texture. So it’s best to freeze it for several hours or overnight for the best scooping. (But I have to admit that I enjoy a serving straight from the ice cream maker before freezing the rest!)

Possible Add-Ins

If you want to add a little something to your homemade ice cream, fold in some mix-ins during the last few minutes of freezing the ice cream in the machine. Here are a few ideas:

• Chopped peanut butter cups
• Spoonfuls of peanut butter, to add a peanut butter swirl
• Reese’s pieces
• Chocolate chips
• Chopped or shaved chocolate bar
• Chopped Heath candy bar or toffee
• Chopped peanuts or other kinds of nuts
• Chopped Oreo cookies
• Crushed waffle cones

Serving Suggestions

We love to turn this ice cream into a sundae, by topping it with some warm hot fudge sauce (easy to make, with just 4 ingredients + 10 minutes of time!). And when we’re feeling extra fancy, we add a swirl of whipped cream and a cherry!

I grew up during the 80’s, when Magic Shell was first introduced…and I have to say, I loved the stuff. So of course I’m a huge fan of eating this ice cream with my homemade magic shell!

Another favorite combo of ours is peanut butter ice cream topped with a big spoon of marshmallow whip, some hot fudge or chocolate sauce, and crushed Oreos. So fun!

Heath candy bar also pairs perfectly with the peanut butter and chocolate fudge – we chop it up and sprinkle it over the top.

Of course, if sundaes aren’t your thing, then you can also scoop peanut butter ice cream into a cone. Waffle cones are a favorite in our house. No bowl or spoon needed to enjoy this frozen treat!

How to Store Homemade Ice Cream

It’s important to store your peanut butter ice cream properly, as it can get freezer burn easily. The easiest way to store homemade ice cream is in a loaf pan. Just pour the ice cream in and keep it tightly wrapped with a double layer of plastic wrap. You can store it in other containers or pans, just be sure that they are freezer-safe and have a tight seal (or wrap them with plastic wrap). You can find many ice scream storage container options on Amazon.

Properly stored, homemade ice cream can last for 2-4 months. But know that fresher is always better. Any ice cream can get icy and take on other flavors from the freezer, depending on how the ice cream is packaged, etc.

More Peanut Butter Recipes:

• Chocolate Peanut Butter No Bake Pie Bars
• Honey Roasted Peanut Butter Cookies
• Buttery Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
• Foolproof Peanut Butter Fudge (2 Ingredients)

Like this recipe? Save it to Pinterest!

This post was originally published in 2010, then updated in 2022.